Home Page
Reviews
DVD Releases
Anime Jargon
Anime Links
Review Stats
Contact Us

Review: Barefoot Gen


TitleBarefoot Gen
Also Known As
FormatOne DVD
Import/LocalImport
Region Coding0 (all regions)
Other Reviews
GenreHistorical Drama
Date Reviewed (YYYY/MM/DD)2002/04/18
Review StatusPreliminary review, pending revision
ReviewerRonny Cook
Ratings
Overall: 8 Personal: 7 Animation: 5 Voice Acting (English): 7
General Audio: 6 Extras: 1 Packaging: 2 Voice Acting (Japanese): -

Plot/Outline

Gen is one of a small family living in Hiroshima in the days immediately before the close of World War 2. Initially we are shown a family hanging together despite hardship and hunger, with Gen a playful and active (if hungry!) young boy, along with his sometimes argumentative younger brother.

Everything changes when the first atomic bomb ever used on a civilian target is dropped over Hiroshima. Flesh melts away in the initial explosion; people are reduced to shadows on the walls behind where they stood. Firestorms blanket the city; people die of a mysterious and unknown illness. Gen and the remaining portion of his family struggle desperately to survive - but also lend help and dignity to others as they can...

Review

Barefoot Gen gives an almost lyrical view of the difficult life in Japan as WW2 draws to a close. The contrast it draws with the horrors of the Bomb's aftermath is pretty deliberate, but also effective. Oddly, most of the characters seem remarkably well-fed despite their protestations, but this appears to be more the animation style than anything else.

The movie has at its core a simple statement: Life goes on. It is a subtext running through almost the entire movie, whereas the folly that led to the Bomb being dropped is touched relatively lightly. The statement you might expect - "This must not be allowed to happen again" - is there, particularly in the immediate aftermath of the Bomb, but the basic message of hope dominates.

This message is in marked contrast to that (allegedly) made by Grave of the Fireflies. As I haven't seen GotF yet, I'm not in a position to say much, but from what I've heard it's a terribly sad film with despair as its central theme, whereas Gen is primarily a message of hope in the midst of unimaginable horror.

No attempt is made to point the finger at the Americans for dropping the Bomb. If anybody is blamed, it is the Japanese high command, who choose to pursue a war which has already been effectively lost. The American bomber and crew are treated impersonally.

Animation quality is not generally high (especially for a feature film) but suits the subject matter. The images surrounding the explosion of the Bomb are horrifyingly well realised, however.

Audio is generally of decent quality, with the period of utter silence as the Bomb explodes focusing the viewer's attention on the horrifying visuals. So far I've only listed to the English dub, which was pretty good.

Packaging is poor - one of those cardboard-cover DVD cases. When the "hub" that holds the DVD breaks, this style of cover risks scratching the DVD, and putting the DVD into a spare case is difficult because the covers can't easily be removed from the remainder of the packaging.

Hide/Show Spoilers

Extras

I don't recall any extras being present (one reason I have to revise this review...)

Wrapup

A good but not great anime. Despite this, if you haven't seen this, you should; its view of Hiroshima is one we would all do well to remember, especially given the light treatment given the consequences of violence in many anime.


Home Page -- Reviews -- Australian Anime DVDs -- Jargon -- Links -- Review Stats
Copyright 2004 Ronny Cook and contributors